Throw a Seed Tier List: Comparison Evidence
Covers Throw a Seed by Fish Time Studios · Place ID 129081220403721 · Updated 2026-11-15
People ask for a tier list and a value list in the same breath. Throw a Seed’s public text has rarities and a luck claim. A trading marketplace is not described in the sources checked, so there is no supported trade-price list. The table below groups available evidence; it does not rank performance.
| Evidence group | Plants or seeds | What is supported | Values needed to rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secret rarity, unnamed | Secret, including 4 new secrets announced in the Update 1 teaser | Called the top end, “1 in a million” | Names, zones, odds beyond that phrase |
| Seen with extra forms | Halo Blossom, Infinity Tree, Thunderhead Tree, UFO Mushroom, Asteroid Oak | A video shows Gold, Diamond, Ruby, Emerald, or Big on them | Income and rarity word |
| Seen as a name | Cherry Blossom, Palm Tree, Shipwreck Tree, Cold Lemon Tree | Readable names, no mutation quoted | Everything else |
| Seeds, unordered | The 11 shop names, plus “new seeds with way more luck” | Better seeds raise luck; new ones are claimed to raise it more | Which seed is better than which |
To rank two seeds, compare their unboosted luck bonuses and prices under the same conditions. Those values are missing for both Crystal Seed and Emerald Seed, so neither can be ranked above the other. Both names appeared in a shop. Neither has a luck number. Update 1’s “way more luck” might refer to seeds that are not even in that list of eleven. Putting the eleven in a ladder would pretend the video’s order was a power order. The public video does not establish a power order.
A useful future ranking needs base cash per second, acquisition conditions, and a clear treatment of mutations and size; rarity alone is not a return-on-cost measure. Until then, use the plant table for names and the guide for what to buy first in words: strength, then a better seed, then garden space. Codes that grant Lucky Throw or a luck potion sit beside this list on the code page; they are consumables, not tiers.
Questions people ask
What is the best seed in Throw a Seed?
No best seed is published. The description says better seeds give more luck, and Update 1 says the new seeds have “way more luck,” without naming a winner.
Why is there no S-tier plant by coins?
Coins per second are blank for every named plant. Ranking them by income would be a guess.
Sources
- Roblox — Throw a Seed — checked 2026-11-15
- Roblox event — Update 1 — checked 2026-11-15
- Raf official TV — first session — checked 2026-11-15
THROW A SEED